is car maintenance more expensive at a dealership

Dealership vs. Local Shop: Car Maintenance Costs

When it comes to taking care of your car, finding the right place for maintenance can make a significant difference in your expenses. Should you choose a dealership or a local mechanic shop? In this article, we will dive into the comparison of car maintenance costs between dealerships and local shops to help you make an informed decision.

Advantages of dealership maintenance:

While local mechanics shops offer convenience and lower prices, there are distinct advantages to opting for dealership maintenance.

The technicians should be highly trained people who specialize in the specific, ensuring that your vehicle receives expert care. They also have access to the latest diagnostic tools and equipment, which may result in more accurate diagnoses and efficient repairs. They will always use branded parts which although they are more expensive will be of high quality.

Saving money on car maintenance:

Contrary to popular belief, dealership maintenance does not always mean inflated costs. Though you should expect to pay more.

By understanding pricing structures and taking advantage of promotions and service packages, you can potentially save money at dealerships.

Additionally, certain maintenance tasks may be covered under warranty or provided at a discounted rate if you purchased your car from the dealership.

Dealership maintenance pricing analysis:

To gain a deeper understanding of dealership maintenance costs, we will analyze and compare the pricing structures offered by dealerships for various maintenance services. From routine tasks like oil changes to more complex repairs, we will provide insights into the cost differences between dealerships and local shops.

Key Takeaways:

  • Dealership maintenance offers advantages such as specialized knowledge and access to advanced equipment.
  • Contrary to popular belief, dealership maintenance can be cost-effective when considering available promotions and warranties. Also future sale price of your vehicle will be increased with main dealer “history”.
  • Comparing pricing structures can help you gauge the potential cost differences between dealerships and local mechanic shops.

Are Car Maintenance Costs More Expensive at a Dealership?

One of the most common concerns when it comes to car maintenance is the associated costs. Many people wonder if getting their car serviced at a dealership will be more expensive compared to an independent mechanic. Let’s dive into the details and compare the costs between these two options.

When looking at car maintenance expenses, it’s important to consider the type of services you require. Let’s take a closer look at some of the common maintenance procedures and how their costs compare between dealerships and independent mechanics:

  1. Oil Changes: Dealerships often have higher labor rates and may charge more for OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) oil, which can make their oil change services more expensive. Independent mechanics, on the other hand, might use aftermarket oil and offer lower labor rates, potentially resulting in lower costs.
  2. Tire Rotations: While the cost for tire rotations can vary, dealerships typically offer competitive prices due to their access to specialized equipment and expertise. Independent mechanics may have lower labor rates, but it’s essential to consider the quality and precision of their services.
  3. Brake Replacements: Dealerships may charge higher prices for brake replacements due to their use of OEM parts. Independent mechanics can often provide aftermarket brake pads at a lower cost while maintaining high-quality performance. It’s crucial to evaluate the warranty and lifespan of the parts used.

Apart from the specific maintenance procedures, dealership service expenses can also be influenced by various factors such as location, brand reputation, and amenities offered. Some dealerships provide additional perks like loaner cars or shuttle services, which may contribute to higher overall costs.

However, it’s important to note that the cost comparison between dealerships and independent garages may not always be straightforward. Factors such as the level of expertise, quality of parts used, and warranty coverage play a significant role in determining the overall value for the price paid.

Comparing dealership and independent garage prices is just one aspect of the decision-making process when it comes to car maintenance. It’s essential to consider other factors like convenience, availability of specialized knowledge for your specific car brand, and the duration of the service.


If you can find a really good, trustworthy local garage then they can save you a lot of money. They won’t use main dealer parts but they will be up to standard. My nephew recently had a quote for £1,200 for discs and pads from the Skoda dealer and the guy I normally use quoted £800.

Now for my young nephew, that price saving was a no-brainer.


After thoroughly analyzing dealership car maintenance costs, it is clear that there are both advantages and potential drawbacks to choosing dealership maintenance for your vehicle. While dealership services may sometimes be more expensive than those offered by local mechanics, it is important to consider the value and expertise they bring to the table.

However, if you are looking to save money on your car maintenance expenses, there are a few tips you can follow regardless of which option you choose. First, make sure to regularly maintain your vehicle and address any issues promptly to avoid more costly repairs down the line. Additionally, educate yourself about the essential maintenance tasks you can handle on your own to reduce reliance on professional services.

Ultimately, the decision between a dealership and a local shop for your car maintenance needs should not be solely based on cost. Other factors to consider include the warranty coverage, specialized knowledge and equipment, and the overall convenience offered by the dealership. Take the time to assess your specific requirements and prioritize what matters most to you before making a well-informed decision.

Read Our Latest Articles Here: